The details of William Pinney’s life seem destined to remain a mystery. His headstone – in Crewkerne Cemetery, Somerset – confirms that he was a Private in the Loyal North Lancashire Regiment, and that he died on 14th August 1919.

The British Army Register of Soldiers’ Effects expands a little on this, identifying that he was in the 2nd Battalion of the regiment. The document states that he died of wounds and had been admitted to the War Hospital in Southampton, Hampshire (this is likely to have been the Royal Victoria Hospital in Netley). It also confirms that his effects were to be passed to his widow, Sarah Pinney.

From this point on, some elements of supposition come in to the research.

There is a marriage certificate for a William Pinney and Sarah Jane Witheyman at the parish church in Crewkerne on 6th January 1911. This record gives William’s age as 23, and shows that he was a weaver and the son of weaver William Pinney Sr. Sarah, meanwhile, was five years older than her new husband, worked as a factory hand, and was the daughter of another factory hand, George Witheyman.

The same year’s census gives more information about William Pinney. He was one of eleven children to William and Mercy Pinney, and every member of the family over school age was involved in weaving and spinning. It should be noted, however, that the census was taken on 2nd April 1911, three months after William’s marriage and, while the ages on the document match, the document states that he is single.

The same census for Sarah tells a similar story. She is noted as being one of twelve children to George and Amelia Witheyman. George is noted as being a ‘hand ackler’, or handyman, while Sarah and the two of her teenage brothers still at home are all working as mill hands. The same anomaly arises as William, however, as she is also noted as being single.

Returning to the marriage certificate, an answer to the anomaly in the dates seems to resolve itself, however. The marriages are noted in chronological order, and the previous wedding to be solemnised in Crewkerne Parish Church was on 26th December 1911, while the following one was on 14th February 1912. It would appear, therefore, that Leonard Jackson, the curate of the church, entered the incorrect date on the certificate.

The census records and marriage certificate all seem to fit the William and Sarah Pinney who were separated by William’s death in 1919. There are certainly no documents suggesting another William Pinney in the Crewkerne area around that time period. It is reasonable to assume, therefore, that they do all connect to the gravestone in the town’s cemetery.

Private Pinney’s military records are missing, or no longer available, so it is not possible to trace his actions during the First World War. The 2nd Battalion of the Loyal North Lancashire Regiment served in India during the first half of the conflict, moving to Egypt in 1917 and to France the following year. It is not possible to confirm where William served, but wherever he fought, he was wounded, and these injuries were to prove fatal. He passed away in the Southampton hospital on 14th August 1919, nine months after the end of the war, aged around 31 years old.